Tuesday, December 1, 2009

India for Beginners

I am mindful of the fact that this collective account is about my travels through Africa. This project, however, has grown tentacles as these initiatives often do. Hence I found myself in India for a week: attendance at the Asian Planning Schools Association conference in Ahmedabad and a visit to the Indian Institute for Human Settlements in Delhi. A week is hardly enough to inform a balanced view - a year would probably just be enough!

India is unlike any place I had been to. It is completely overwhelming: the colour, the crowds and the constant traffic noise. Hooting has replaced traffic signals and conventions as a means of communication. I tried to deconstruct the code. A short friendly little playful honk: 'be careful I am about to change two lanes at once and you are in the way'; a longer insistent but not terribly agressive hoot: 'don't veer into my lane because the vehicle on your other side is about to do so by changes two lanes...'; a loud and aggressive hoot is reserved for slow drivers, non-motorised transport users and those paying attention to traffic signals....

I was able to make this (probably flawed) analysis from the back of a three-wheeler, ubiquitous little vehicles that dodge traffic with enormous skill, are cheap and appear to be available anywhere at any time. Apparently these little gems of mobility run on two-stroke engines and provided a much needed source of employment with Ahmedabad's textile industry restructured in the 1990s. Travelling in them is an adventure as they dodge buses and cross 3-lane traffic circles with ease. I could touch some of the vehicles we overtook and intercepted!

Besides its textiles, the city of Ahmedabad is famous for its 400-year heritage and intends to have its walled area declared a World Heritage site. Quite what that means for the city and its inhabitants remains unclear to me. The symbols of its Jain, Hindu and Islamic heritage are stunning. Colourful and intricately carved temple exteriors provides community focal points for the various pols (enclosed neighbourhoods) and elegant chabutras (bird feeders) emphasise small public squares where narrow lanes converge. Juxtaposed with these elements of ancient urban design are buildings designed by Le Corbusier, Doshi, Louis Khan and Charles Correa. Paradoxically, the former plunges one into the chaos of the city whilst these latter monuments to the machine age and the proud era of post-colonial India provide solace from the din of street traffic. Khan's Institute of Management is impressive in an intimadating and inaccessible way. Correa's work I love. I spent a whole afternoon inGhandi's ashram as a testiment to the great man but also to revel in the beautifully articulated spaces that so effortlessly interface with the lush natural surroundings.

In an article entitled 'How to be a Cultural Superpower' the Times of India outlines 3 easy steps: export Indian items such as yoga, cinema and ayurveda; open Indian cultural centres in major capitals and offer subsidised courses teaching appreciation of Indian culture. It strikes me that all this is unnecessary. India does not need to try so hard.

2 comments:

  1. great, any chance of going on an even bigger tanget and writing a blog on your food experiences (with culture and planning intertwined: where do people eat, transport hubs, street food, grocery shopping habits etc...). I would post it on my www.eatcapetown.co.za facebook group.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nancy - you have summarised the 'etiquette' of Indian driving perfectly. It took me nearly 2 years into my stint in Mumbai to come up with the same conclusions. I instructed my driver that he was only allowed to use the horn in one of 2 instances - we were going to be killed or we were going to kill someone! He started to use his lights to flash people which I found acceptable!! One of my other friends in Mumbai had his horn disconnected from the drivers wheel & a button installed in the back so only he could use it - his driver was apparently out of sorts for days! My favourite was still Calcutta - they have a one way system that operates from 06.00 - 15.00 in one direction & then reverses - good idea, trouble is you need to let one lot of traffic filter out before you open the other side. In addition, the bus and taxi drivers said the one way system was impacting their business so they were exempt from the ruling - no bus or taxi lane was provided though. There is nothing like sitting in a Mahindra Ambassador (felt like riding in a wheel barrow with a flat tyre), middle of a monsoon deluge, in rush hour traffic where the cars are separated by a hairs length & then catching site of a Ashok Leyland bus (all the drivers dooors had the word 'Pilot' painted on them) coming straight at you!! Andrew

    ReplyDelete